Reviews:

This is a small place with mostly a take-out clientele but that's not a bad thing; the food quality is anything but ordinary take out.
The online menu with pictures is appetizing enough and the prices are also appealing.
The Stromboli's are incredible. They come with a marinara dipping sauce and are something you can't stop eating. The sausage and pepper rolls are my favorite of these. The Antipasto Salad is totally incredible! The giardiniera makes this one really special. There is so much fresh lettuce, onions, black olives, jardinière, pepperoni, Genoa salami, ham, provolone, and mozzarella cheese that its totally a meal in itself. Strangely enough the only thing I'm not really thrilled about here is the pizza. It's not bad and I would give it a solid B+ compared to the other stuff out there but, I'm a NY Pizza fanatic and this is not what I'm looking for. That said, there is still plenty to love about this place and I highly recommend it.

Their pizzas are used to be good but it's going downhill Bizzaorro is since they moved into gas station is not the same

Horrible.  It's not Bizarro Pizza anymore it Hob's.   And they are the rudest people. I have ever met.  Waited hrs for a pizza that never came the charged me and when 3 hrs passed and could not get them on phone went there to find please  closed. It was only 730pm.    Have Benny trying to find owners name but seems to be a ghost.

I wouldn't get pizza from this spot again. We ordered delivery and the pizza was a pool of cheese. I REALLY like cheese, but this was just way too much. It's too bad, because I thought the thin crust was decent, but I'll be looking elsewhere for a local delivery joint.

Good pizza. I love the giant slices it reminds me of back home in New York. Friendly staff!!!

Went into Bizzarro's after all the good reviews and ordered large pepperoni pizza with light sauce an hour later they come out with a pizza with extra sauce and a few pieces of pepperoni on it. Had to go home and put it back in my oven to cook it and the sauce on the pizza was not too good. That place was not for me. I do not recommend that place.

We ordered a Bizzaro special while staying overnight in Cocoa. When we called to place an order the phone rang and rang and rang. I figured they may have been screening their calls because they did not want to deliver to our hotel. I called right back from my cell phone and the call was answered by the second ring. Hmmmm. Weird because their laminated menu is the one in the room.

The pizza was ok. The slices were huge but the sauce just didn't have much flavor. It definitely wasn't the worst pizza I ever had but wasn't near the best. If this pizza place was in my hometown I would not be a frequent customer.

In a nutshell, pizza was just ok, prices were reasonable, and they did not seem very happy to take orders from the hotel guests.

This was my favorite NY style Pizza, but then Hurricane Erma came through they had to shut down because of damage, I guess they lost all the people that knew what they were doing because there service went down hill put on hold twice for 10 min. And almost 2 hours the first time. A week later one and half hours and I get a burnt pizza and they changed their sausage. I'll try again in a couple weeks but this is sad. They were awesome.

Always so good, but this time it was way too much garlic. I am still tasting it in my toothbrush 2 days later. That is disgusting.  
The cheese is divine and the crust is always so perfect...there is no need to over do it with the extras..where ya don't need extras!!!!!! This place doesn't need any help!!!! They do good all by them selves!!!

I miss Bobby already.  Pizza still tastes good, but... 1.  I asked for pies to be left in about 2 minutes longer than normal.  they were both still barely golden brown.  2.  i had 2, no more than 3 slices of pepperoni per slice on my pepperoni pizza.  3.  asked for extra sauce on pepperoni, didn't get it.  4. no more draft beer.

This is not any where close to as good as Bizzarro's on MI. Where are the toppings and extra cheese??? 2" of crust, I will stick to MI. Was in the area and thought I'd give it a try. Plus it was more than what online menu said!  Disappointed!

I don't post many reviews on Yelp but I was pleasantly surprised to come across this delicious pizza place on my way to the Treasure Coast from MCO.

Reminds me of NY style pizza. Huge slices are as big as your face with tasty sauce and cheese. Cheap as heck- don't be turned away from the connected gas station. Really nice employees and service was great. This place is legit.

Spent .72 with this app they did not honor the free drink on this app thumbs down will not go back service horrible

What Happened? This used to be my favorite place and now tastes like gas station pizza. The crust used to be thin, brown and crispy.  Now it is all dough and grease.

Name and receipe sold to new owner.  It was good, but not what I was hoping for when going to Bizarro's.

I always liked Bizarro's pizza. The staff at this location was very courteous, nice and thoughtful. Its in a convenient location and would definitely come back again.

I absolutely love their pizza. Bizarros has some really great deals, especially if you choose pick up instead of delivery.

My family often chooses meaty pizza and their meat lovers pizza is amazing.

Friendly staff, clean restaurant, and a great price. Can't beat it for the quality.

Amazing Staff. Kiddos enjoyed the tv while we enjoyed our dinner  Food was good. Very kid friendly. Peaceful environment

This place can be easy to miss since it looks as though it is in a gas station. However, it is actually located attached to the gas station and not inside it :)

What is even more amazing is that they have a couple of tables for seating and while they serve their Pizzas and Rolls in really cheap paper plates (which have to be doubled up) and  plastic forks/knives...it servers beer on tap and wine!

The prices are very reasonable and the pizza slices are huge. The crust is also really good but was disappointed with the rolls on their menu.

We might just order take out next time which is a shame because the employees there are really nice and very friendly.

The pizza was great.  The owner or manager was a nice guy.  He told me the pizza is New York style thin crust.  At first I thought I wanted two pizzas, but he asked how many I was feeding and I told him two adults and three kids.  Then he told me the 18 inch was more than enough and to just do 1/2 and 1/2.  The pizza was so good that my picky 5 year old devoured it...and the pizza was cut into huge pieces.  The most memorable thing however was that my car wouldn't start.  I needed a jump and one of the delivery guys was more than happy to help me.  Great pizza and even greater people!  Thanks!